The Ninth Circuit affirmed the denial of LendingTree's motion to compel arbitration in a privacy class action, ruling its website lacked conspicuous notice of arbitration terms. This forces LendingTree to face class action litigation rather than individual arbitration, potentially increasing legal costs and liability.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a lower court's decision against LendingTree, preventing the company from forcing individual arbitration in a privacy class action. This ruling is significant because it means LendingTree will now have to defend itself against a class action lawsuit, which typically carries higher financial risks and potential liabilities compared to individual arbitrations. The court found LendingTree's website failed to adequately inform users of its arbitration terms, setting a precedent for how online platforms must present such agreements. In the short term, this increases LendingTree's legal expenses and potential settlement or judgment costs. Long-term, it may prompt LendingTree and other online service providers to review and revise their website terms and conditions presentation to ensure enforceability, creating a potential operational risk for companies with similar user agreement practices.